What Emery blamed for Gomes mistake as McGinn admits Barcelona 'learning curve'

But goals conceded through mistakes and missed chances would surely have left a sense of frustration on the flight home from Barcelona to the Midlands.

Villa started the game in nightmare fashion as Joao Gomes blindly played the ball across his own box, allowing Lamine Yamal to intercept and find the far corner, beating Zion Suzuki.

After dropping to the ground and beating the turf in frustration, Gomes then had a chance to atone for his error just moments later when the ball fell invitingly for him inside the box at the other end from a corner, but his effort was blocked.

Indeed, Villa responded well to falling behind, especially considering the manner of Yamal’s goal, but one theme of the match was that they did not take their chances when they arrived.

Barcelona were missing several defenders through injury and also play a dangerously high defensive line, with Nicolas Jackson no doubt licking his lips before the game. In fact, before hosting Villa, Barcelona hadn’t kept a clean sheet in the Champions League for 18 games, stretching back 18 months to April 2025.

Jackson should have done better when he reached the ball before Joan Garcia after being played in by Johan Manzambi. The two had combined for another good chance just moments earlier, with Manzambi dragging his effort wide of the far post.

Barcelona, though, had scored three or more goals in 11 of their matches this season before Tuesday night, so giving them a leg up with an early mistake was the last thing Villa needed to do. Still, Emery took some responsibility for Gomes’ mistake in his post-match press conference, insisting that the midfielder was playing as he wanted him to.

“Gomes started not very confident with the ball,” Emery said. “The mistake is part of our style, I am not blaming him. Before the mistake, he lost two balls. Today is a very good experience for him. We have made mistakes like that in four years and we always overcame those mistakes.”

Between Gomes, Ross Barkley and Leon Goretzka, each midfielder offers different qualities, not only in terms of technical ability but also temperament and perhaps even reliability in terms of fitness.

Directly replacing Youri Tielemans was never going to happen for £35 million, so Emery decided to recruit a different type of midfielder whom he could mould. However, based on the first few months of this season, there are question marks over how close Gomes can get to matching Tielemans’ on-ball ability.

Perhaps it means there will be greater dependence on Barkley’s ability to control matches, something Gomes has struggled to do at times since joining, having looked too nervous in possession, particularly at Camp Nou.

Get the best Villa news, updates and analysis from John Townley and more, straight to your Inbox!

To get it, it's a quick and easy one-two:

Villa’s defeat was not solely down to Gomes’ mistake - that much must be clear - because they had enough chances to be leading at half-time despite their poor start.

“When you come to places like this, you need to start well and weather the storm,” captain McGinn said on TNT Sports. “We didn’t do that tonight. They started very intensely and very fast, but even in that spell we had chances and should have made better decisions.

“I think we are competitive against teams at this level, we have shown that whether it is Bayern Munich or PSG. Tonight was a huge learning curve for us and I am sure it will stand us in good stead for the future.”

Make sure you never miss the latest Aston Villa news and opinion by making Birmingham Live one of your Google preferred sources.

You can follow our dedicated reporter John Townley on X by clicking here - he follows Villa home and away and offers you comprehensive coverage from matchdays, press conferences and everything that happens in between.

You'll also get competition offers and stories around discounts on Villa merchandise.

WhatsApp: You can also get all your favourite content from BirminghamLive's Villa team on WhatsApp. Click here to sign up for breaking updates about the biggest stories in and around the club.If you prefer reading our Villa stories on your phone, consider downloading the BirminghamLive app, in which you can personalise the content you see by selecting Villa as one of your designated topics. You can get it from Apple here and for Android here.

Social: We have a Facebook page waiting for you with daily updates, some of which we don't post anywhere else - click here

You can also folllow our Villa updates on X - here

Podcast: Our weekly Aston Villa podcast, Claret And Blue, is also available to watch and listen on all major streaming services. You can subscribe to the YouTube channel here, while you can access the podcast on Spotify here and via Apple here.