National media make firm Liverpool midfield point as transfer question posed

Liverpool Echo · Paul Gorst

The ECHO, as ever, was at the game to provide an exhaustive match-day experience. You can find our player ratings, big-match verdict, on-the-whistle reaction and our considered analysis all here.

If you want to relive the live action, our dedicated match blog is here. You can also get the reactions of Iraola and Newcastle boss Matthias Jaissle here.

But how did our colleagues from the national media view things? For the first time this season, here's what they were saying after a Liverpool game.

Paul Joyce, of The Times, writes: "After first heading over to acknowledge the Liverpool supporters still celebrating up in the gods, Andoni Iraola then marched towards the tunnel and was deep in conversation with Dominik Szoboszlai as he did so.

"How to take the perfect penalty probably came up given the nerveless manner in which one of his new vice-captains had thrashed a 99th-minute spot kick into the top corner to eke out a point.

"The challenge Szoboszlai, and countless others, failed to put in on Yoane Wissa in the build-up to Newcastle United’s second goal? Well, that was a conversation for another time.

"Preferably today, tomorrow and the day after until Liverpool start to take their responsibilities with regard to the art of defending a little more seriously.

"Another dramatic denouement in this fixture at least demonstrated a desire to push to the end, but the focus for Iraola must now be strengthening the soft underbelly which will check another season’s ambitions until it is rectified."

On the pages of The Telegraph, Dominic King pens: "It had to end that way, didn’t it? A last-minute goal, a sense of what might have been and a helter-skelter contest that will take days to decipher.

"Newcastle versus Liverpool became the Premier League’s most dramatic fixture when Kevin Keegan was manager here and, on the afternoon they flocked to the 'cathedral on the hill' to pay tribute to the late, great superstar, we were treated to a contest that was in keeping with his narrative.

"Liverpool operating with the discipline of a basketball team undoubtedly helped, and we can examine those gaping chasms soon enough, but the poignancy of seeing Matthias Jaissle looking as bereft as Keegan at Anfield 30 years ago at the final whistle was impossible to ignore.

"Really, the German’s first match in charge of Newcastle should have ended with three points. His team are a work in progress – rich in youthful exuberance though prone to lapses – but how they fought, ran and worked to give the locals the result they wanted.

"They were almost at the finish line, seconds away from beating Liverpool here for the first time since December 2015, but then Lewis Hall ran into Victor Munoz, sending the Spanish substitute sprawling, and Stuart Attwell pointed to the penalty spot. Dominik Szoboszlai inflicted maximum damage."

Writing for The Independent, Richard Jolly mused: "For Liverpool and Newcastle alike, the new came with certain lashes of the old, and not merely Szoboszlai’s relish for the occasion. Liverpool had (Alexander) Isak’s latest ineffectual showing. Newcastle conceded too many injury-time goals last season and began the current campaign with another.

"They have lost out to Liverpool for too many players: Hugo Ekitike last summer, who then scored against them home and away, and Munoz this, who made his mark in his cameo. 'I am happy for Victor,' said Iraola. 'He has created problems.'

"It gave the new head coach an immediate return from a signing he championed; while Liverpool still need a right winger, on the afternoon Mohamed Salah opened his Trabzonspor account, Munoz at least showed his speed with a surge on the right. Liverpool could savour another debut, the giant Jeremy Jacquet showing huge promise at the heart of their defence.

"And yet, when the anguish of added time dissipates, Newcastle may derive more encouragement from this. Eddie Howe’s departure seemed to plunge them into chaos. Only 18 days after his appointment was announced, Jaissle’s frantic football instead left Liverpool looking dishevelled."

The Daily Mail's Lewis Steele reflected: "The chief problem for new boss Andoni Iraola was the midfield – or lack thereof. Both goals were accomplished counter-attacks from Newcastle but both were highly preventable as Liverpool were cut through at ease.

"This summer has been all about replacing Mohamed Salah, who scored on his Trabzonspor league debut on Sunday, but why has there been no attempts to sign a midfielder?

"It is not like this is a new problem. Alexis Mac Allister and Gravenberch were both poor for the entirety of last season and Liverpool have needed a deep-lying player since Fabinho left in the summer of 2023.

"At Bournemouth, [Iraola] played with an energetic and dynamic double-pivot of Tyler Adams and Lewis Cook. So far, the Basque boss seems unsure about the make-up of his top-heavy midfield. How to get the best of Wirtz and Szoboszlai but also keep the team solid?

"It is now over to those upstairs to ensure the impressive Iraola has the tools to thrive this season, as the bench looked weak. A winger or two would be great but a new holding midfielder should join the wide forwards at the top of that shopping list."

And the ECHO's verdict reads: "If Liverpool's recruitment team are smart, Dominik Szoboszlai's impeccable penalty that earned a 2-2 draw here at Newcastle United won't factor into their thinking this next week or so.

"For supporters, their mood on the long journey back towards Merseyside will have been immeasurably improved by Szoboszlai's near-perfect penalty in the 99th minute, of course.

"But the smash-and-grab nature of the Reds' latest dramatic intervention at St James' Park should not influence a department who have much work to do to furnish head coach Andoni Iraola with the sort of squad he needs to make sure there is no hangover from last year's deeply troubled term.

"Those who are tasked with adding to the Liverpool squad before the 11pm deadline on September 1 should not be thrown off course by what should ultimately be viewed as a creditable draw to kick off the Iraola era.

"Because this squad is nowhere near complete and the coming days are critical as a result.

"Iraola, in full fairness to him, hasn't shied away from the fact that he needs more, speaking quite openly about the club's determination to add some wingers to the ranks before deadline day.

"But on this evidence, Liverpool need to reassess the idea that they are not in need of a defensive-minded midfielder who will allow the more creatively gifted talents to thrive further forward."

Read on Liverpool Echo

More from Liverpool

Milos Kerkez sparks Virgil van Dijk reaction as Liverpool respond to Alexander Isak abuseLiverpool EchoTurkish media make immediate Mohamed Salah U-turn after Liverpool hero's display for TrabzonsporLiverpool EchoAlexander Isak and Florian Wirtz get reality check in defining moment for Liverpool careersLiverpool EchoPremier League: 10 talking points from opening weekend of the seasonThe GuardianArbeloa v Alonso: Benitez on his former players turned managersBBC Sport
Prefer a machine-readable version? View as Markdown