
What Harry Kane did to Lewis Hall should send alarm bells ringing at Newcastle
In the Madrid cauldron last night, the display of Lewis Hall sent a cocktail of emotions surging through the bodies of most Newcastle United fans. Pride, regret, concern, joy and fear all rolled into one big ball of anxiety.
What happens over the next six months will determine which of those feelings takes over from the others. Is your glass half-full or half-empty?
If it's half-full then you are looking at Hall and thinking 'Newcastle have one of the best left-backs in the world on their books'. A player they can build Newcastle 2.0 (copyright David Hopkinson) around, a Toon fan who signed a six-year contract in the summer and who is still just 22 years old. If it's half-empty, then you fear he will be headhunted by the biggest clubs in the world and Newcastle have already found with Anthony Gordon, Bruno Guimaraes and Alexander Isak that when the elite come in, there's no holding back the river.
Madrid on Sunday night was a movie Newcastle had seen before. Hall up against the winger regarded as the best in the world, producing a defensive display that was a mix of discipline, swift recovery runs and skill, while at the same time having the confidence to drive his team forward the other way. That mazy run inside the first 10 minutes was electrifying but nothing proud Newcastle fans haven't enjoyed many a time over the last 12 months.
It was Hall's performance in the first leg of Newcastle's Champions League last 16 clash against Barcelona back in March which set the standard. That night, he pickpocketed Lamine Yamal with ease, to the point where the superstar Spaniard became anonymous until an injury-time penalty which the young winger converted to give Barcelona a scarcely-deserved draw. It was arguably the turning point of the tie, Newcastle's season and the rest of Eddie Howe's reign as manager - if they'd headed to the Camp Nou for the second leg with a lead it could have been a different story. Plenty to regret.
The way Hall shone against Yamal that night brought him to the attention of the world, not just the Premier League. It made Thomas Tuchel's decision not to take him to the World Cup in the summer even more bizarre, although Hall - like many of his Newcastle teammates - did suffer a dip in form after the Camp Nou hammering.
What it did mean, however, was that Hall wasn't in the spotlight over the summer, or privy to the squad camp gossip, both of which unsettled Guimaraes at the World Cup. While Arsenal came calling for their skipper, Newcastle fought off the advances of Manchester United, instead tying Hall down to a bumper new deal.
It was the best deal they struck during the summer, better than the £100m they received for Sandro Tonali, but it will count for nothing if they don't give Hall the platform he deserves on Tyneside.
The best left-back in England - and now one of the top five in the world - simply won't accept his career dwindling away in a team battling relegation. Unless Newcastle provide a side befitting of his abilities, that new contract will be no shield against the charge of Europe's elite when the transfer window reopens next summer. That's the fear. That's the big concern.
Forget Man Utd. Hall's performances against Yamal on Sunday will have spiked the interest of Barcelona and Real Madrid. Barca will be in the market for a new left-back next summer after Alejandro Balde's fall from favour with Hansi Flick meant playing right-siders Xavi Espart and Joao Cancelo out of position. A left-sided reunion with Gordon would be electric.
You can bet your life that Bayern Munich's decision-makers - sick of the class Alphonso Davies being permanently crocked - have spoken to Harry Kane about his England team-mate too. The Three Lions skipper noticeably made a beeline for the youngster after the win over Spain to congratulate him on his performance.
The statistics tell their own story. Hall ranked highest for defensive interventions in the first half while having more successful dribbles than any other player - Yamal included. He created one big chance, had two interceptions, won eight out of his 10 defensive duels and had a 90% pass accuracy.
Everything you want in a modern full-back.
This isn't a bid to sell Lewis Hall, by the way. But it is a warning. There is nothing more that any Newcastle United fan wants than to see him stay at St James' Park for the next decade. Recency bias often takes over but the youngster is arguably already the greatest left-back we've seen in a black and white shirt, an accolade he could cement over the next 10 years.
But for that to happen, Newcastle must step up. Ross Wilson and Matthias Jaissle between them must deliver the players and side that matches Hall's ability and ambition. Being a Newcastle fan will only keep him on Tyneside for so long.
Newcastle have a transfer window in January in which Wilson can act on the first part; then it is up to Jaissle to sort the second piece of the puzzle. The German clearly has a strong relationship with his star man but it is a short career and a close pals act will only stretch so far when it comes to the player deciding where he wants to spend his best years.
"It has been a weird season," Hall told Chronicle Live at the weekend. "We have shown in spells what a great team we can be. We have a young squad, but it's only going to get better and better."
That hope and belief needs to be turned into a reality if Newcastle are to ensure Hall doesn't become the next superstar to quit for pastures new.